nonexpert, it really does feel like you just wish to attack, please just stop. This topic has nothing to do with Catholics, or apostates... there are other threads that deal with this (or as Misty said, one can be started). Do you know the definition of rhetorical (and please dont post the definition here, everyone has google and this question is also rhetorical)? A wise man once said, It is better to keep quiet and appear a fool than to speak and remove all doubt.

The Dude Abides